Kremlin Contradicts US — Europe NOT Agreed for Next Ukraine Talks, as Donbas-for-NATO Pitch Is Picked Apart
Russia has not agreed to European representatives joining the next round of Ukraine peace talks, a top Kremlin aide said on Monday — directly contradicting what the US negotiators said after meeting President Vladimir Putin in Moscow.
Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov told reporters that the current discussion concerns another round in a three-sided format, involving Russia, Ukraine and the United States. The two US envoys, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, had said after meeting Putin last Thursday that he had agreed to Europe taking part in the next round. Ushakov did not respond directly to the US statements, but he was clear that no date has been set for the next round, and that the talks resumed in Abu Dhabi a few days ago with an agreement to carry on in the same three-sided format.
The contradiction matters because Europe's leaders thought they were already in. On Friday, after meeting in Dublin, they agreed to send a five-country team — Britain, France, Germany, Italy and Poland, alongside EU officials — into the process Kushner is brokering. European Council President António Costa said "only Ukraine has the legitimacy to decide on matters concerning its territory and sovereignty." Moscow's answer, two days later, is that Ukraine's territory is only half the conversation — the other half is Europe's security order.
That wider conversation is now being picked apart in public. Al Jazeera has published an explainer on the idea at the centre of it: the United States has suggested Ukraine could become a NATO member if it ceded control of the Donbas region in the east, which Putin has demanded as one of his conditions for ending the war. President Volodymyr Zelenskyy said on Saturday that Kushner and Witkoff had put the question to him at the latest round of US-mediated talks in Abu Dhabi last week: "What if Ukraine joins NATO? Would Ukraine withdraw from Donbas?" He said it was the first time the idea had been raised, and he reiterated that Kyiv would not give up any of its territories. Ukraine applied to join NATO in September 2022.
The Kremlin has not yet responded to the Donbas-for-NATO proposal, but it has maintained that Ukraine joining NATO is a red line and a direct threat to Russia's national security. The United States has not explicitly announced that it suggested Kyiv should cede territory for NATO membership. On Saturday, hours after Zelenskyy's remarks, Kushner wrote on X that "the press has reported some of the maximalist positions proposed by both sides, along with strong political rhetoric", and stressed that the conversations were "private discussions" aimed at ending the war. He added that NATO will remain a "critical pillar" of European security, with credible security guarantees for Ukraine, and that both sides understand practical compromises will be needed.
The maximalist positions are now on the record. In a document circulated during the Abu Dhabi talks, dated 10 November, Russia set out demands reaching well beyond ending the war — reported by the New York Times, the Economist and Ukrainian outlets from leaked documents. Moscow wants NATO troops removed from Central and Eastern Europe and a halt to further NATO enlargement, a return of NATO's military presence to 1997 levels, an end to Western weapons deliveries to Ukraine, and non-aggression pacts with individual European countries — deals that, as Al Jazeera notes, could undercut NATO's principle that an attack on one of its 32 members is an attack on all. Russia would keep everything it occupies and receive the rest of Donbas. Moscow has also not accepted Kyiv's idea of freezing the conflict along the present front line.
The Kremlin raised the stakes further on Sunday, when spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Russia would use force to achieve its goals if it could not reach a security agreement with Europe. Kushner, meanwhile, says his focus is now on facilitating direct engagement between Moscow and European partners and preparing the agenda for the next round of trilateral talks. The open question is a phone call: whether Europe's five-country team picks up the channel Kushner has opened — and what Moscow does if it does not.

Comments
Post a Comment